Originally titled Keep Hope Alive. Olesya Rulin played Sabrina, the new love interest for Jimmy. Kate Micucci was cast as Jimmy's cousin. The role was originally created as a male named Mike. Fox decided to recast two roles from the pilot. Shannon Woodward replaced Olesya Rulin as Sabrina, Jimmy's new love interest. Also recast was the role of Jimmy's cousin, and the role reverted to male with the addition of Skyler Stone as Mike. With this, Kate Micucci's role changed from Jimmy's cousin to become Shelly, the cousin of his love interest Sabrina